Sheetz Pepperoni Pizza

Sheetz is not known for their pizza, and after trying their pepperoni slice, I can tell why. It’s really nothing to write home about, but, for a 5 dollar pie, it’s honestly better than I thought it would be. However, its lack of crunch, rubbery cheese, and overall way-too-salty taste, forced us to dock some points.

Garrett: 5.3|Dane: 4.2|John: 5.3|Jeromie: 4.2

Average score of 4.8/10

Little Caesar’s

For a place whose slogan is “pizza pizza,” their pizza makers could use a little more training. The crust was so inconsistent in thickness. As Jeromie put it, “It has the ingredients to be a great pizza.” Not a huge fan of the lack of sizes on the website, but one thing that Little Caesar’s gets some respect for is the price. A large pizza for 9 dollars is fantastic. This doesn’t change the fact that the overall taste of the pizza was rather bland.

Garrett: 6.5|Dane: 5.2|John: 5.4|Jeromie: 5.3

Average score of 5.6/10

Fox’s Pizza Den

Sauce is a huge aspect of a pizza, and I believe nobody does sauce better than Fox’s. Undoubtably, Matthew, Dane, and I are biased as we do work there, but the latter two of us tried to keep our reviews as unbiased and honest as possible. Steaming as soon as we opened the box, our first bites may have burnt all of our mouths. Based on structure, the pizza was very, very cheesy. As a result, there was no crunch, and the front was super droopy. Kind of like eating a lasagna with one hand, it was difficult to keep it all together. Anyway, Fox’s still tasted very solid.

Garrett: 6.8|Dane: 6.1|John: 7.1|Jeromie: 6.2

Average score of 6.6/10